The Icon and the Axe

But Magnitsky had made too many enemies, and his main friend, Arakcheev, had fallen from power. Having ridden the wave of obscurantism, he was now swept aside into the stagnant backwaters of the provincial civil service from which he was to witness the success of the policies he advocated without benefiting from them. He wrote briefly for a journal bearing a title from the symbolism of higher Masonic orders: The Rainbow. But his last writings represent only a broken-spirited endorsement of his longstanding anti-rationalism: a treatise on astrology and a series called "simple thinker," which defended the unquestioning faith of "muzhik Christianity."108

The Legacy

Under Catherine and Alexander, Russia had moved deep into Europe physically and spiritually but had not equipped itself to share in the political and institutional development of the West. Russian cities had been rebuilt on neo-classical models, but Russian thought had remained largely untouched by classical form and discipline. An experiment that had begun with Catherine's promise to provide the most tolerant and rational rule in Europe had ended with Magnitsky's intolerance and glorification of the Mongols. Imprecise hopes had given way to equally vague fears without the major problems being defined, let alone solved. The debate was cut off before Russia had achieved either a rationalized political system or a rational theology; and the imperial government committed itself to the difficult reactionary position of simply preventing the questions from being asked.

The religious purge of 1824 ended all broad discussion of belief within the official Church, just as the repression of the Decembrists the following year ended all discussion of basic political questions within the government. But expectations once raised are not easily dispelled. Denied a hearing in official circles, the problems continued to agitate Russia unofficially.

Indeed, the leading agitators of the Alexandrian age acquired in martyrdom an historical significance they had been unable to gain in action. The trial and humiliation of the Decembrists left a keen impact on the newly awakened moral sensibilities of the aristocracy. Having been unable to agree on their own political program, the aristocratic thinkers were united by their opposition to the spectacle of a "generation on trial" and by their revulsion at the execution of the leaders and the sanctioning of odes in praise of those throwing mud at others en route to Siberian exile. The "Hannibalic oath" of Herzen and Ogarev to avenge the fallen Decembrists is the real starting point of Russia's modern revolutionary tradition.

Equally remarkable was the continued appeal throughout Nicholas' reign of the new religious answers that had been offered under his predecessor. The Catholic Church attracted many Russian aristocrats-particularly after the official anti-Catholicism that accompanied the crushing of the Polish rebellion. The beautiful Zinaida Volkonsky, a close friend of Alexander I and former maid of honor to the dowager empress, became a leading figure in Catholic charity work in Rome and an apostle of reunification of the churches and conversion of the Jews.109 Sophia Svechin, the daughter of one of Catherine's leading advisers, became a leading benefactress of the Jesuit order in Paris. She set up a chapel and Slavic library and helped induce a young diplomat, Ivan Gagarin, to join the order.110 The Decembrist Lunin became a Catholic and the freethinker Pecherin a Redemptorist friar ministering to the poor of Dublin. Most remarkable of all was the conversion of a large part of the Golitsyn family, which had pioneered since the seventeenth century in the secular Westernization of Russia. Dmitry Golitsyn, son of Diderot's main Russian contact, joined the Church and went to Baltimore, Maryland, where he became the first Catholic priest to receive all his orders in the United States. Ordained in 1795, he led a Sulpician mission to western Pennsylvania, administering a vast area stretching from Harrisburg to Erie, Pennsylvania, from a log church near the present town of Loretto.111

Prophetic sectarianism continued also to exercise an appeal. The various "spiritual Christians" in the south continued to flourish: the "milk drinkers" in the Caucasus, whence they were deported in 1823 and began establishing new contacts extending into Persia; the "spirit bearers" in the

Cossack center of Novocherkassk, where various followers of Kotel'nikov told of his martyrdom in Solovetsk and predicted the end of the world in 1832, 1843, and 1844.112